![]() |
Dying Fields: In depth PBS documentary on Vidarbha farmer suicides
by ameetdesh on Sep 28, 2007      Category: Economics & Business Tags: india economics video crisis documentary farming suicide
made in Aug2007. 800 farmers have commited suicides since Jan 2007. Learn the role BT Cotton seeds, erratic monsoon, debt traps, dowry practice, cotton prices, American subsidies, free trade act play in this. Read the "Handbook" to understand broader economic picture of this problem. A thorough, unbiased, urging documentary.
up
8 users have voted.
ameetdesh
I am doctoral student at UC San Diego. I am interested in Economics and role of appropriate Technology in development and education. With the internet, the world has become a small place, with best practices in various fields accessible at mouseclick. In future I would like to play such rolw of a cr.....read more
10 Comments

recent comments
vishwa
on कंपनी का करोड़पति बनाने का दावा ( ONLY 66 DAYS)
Is he same person who running golden fruit capital pvt lt in bangalore
Devvrit
on REQUIRED STUDENTS FOR INTERNSHIP IN DELHI BASED NGO SVCT
Hi... I want an Internship in Science Related Field, probably in Physics And Mathematics Side...It...
shenajedyj
on IBNLive : Sagarika Ghose's Blog : Red Letter Day
The love in her side
Annabelle was much liked the Korean’s dramas, it was romantic and beautiful....
shenafcqze
on IBNLive : Sagarika Ghose's Blog : Red Letter Day
The love in her side
Annabelle was much liked the Korean’s dramas, it was romantic and beautiful....
shenajedyj
on IBNLive : Sagarika Ghose's Blog : Red Letter Day
The love in her side
Annabelle was much liked the Korean’s dramas, it was romantic and beautiful....










Comments
Recently came across AID petition for candle light vigil for this problem. It led me to this documentary. The AID petition is very welcome, as it asks government to provide immediate relief to these farmers. (debt waiver, min cotton price, relief package) but found clauses about providing grants for organic farming, and subsidies for organic farmers for competing in global market. I feel organic farming though environmentally sustainable, is not economically sustainable in India without subsidies/ intensive training/ targeted market which is willing to pay more for organic food. It is surely welcome step, but is not the solution of Vidarbha's woes. A quick sustainable help would be training in rainwater harvesting, drip irrigation, training in cultivating BT cotton and accessible subsidized loans & insurance policies.
From the documentary, I would like to know more about following questions.
Why do people go cotton, and not any other crop? What has affected its market prices? (free trade act, min support price, import, city based retailers) Why is BT cotton more prone to irrigation uncertainties, than traditional? How does its cost & yield compare against traditional varieties? How does it affect soil fertility? Exactly how is BT cotton an addiction, as Vandana Shiva mentions? (why it leads to initial good, but worse consequences over time & why cant people go back?) Can microfinance help? (Farmer's cooperative?) Why can't banks fulfill the niche, local moneylenders are trying to fill? How does drinking affect this problem & farm productivity? How does land size & size of family affect this crisis?
Good set of questions :)
Ameet, here are answers to some of your questions.
Cotton is a cash crop and per hectare earning is much more than cereals, hence preferred.
BT was developed for large scale cotton farming in US and has following pros and cons:
Pros:
- High resistance to common pests, so no pesticide requirements.
- High yields (claimed by some, refuted by some). But, I believe there is some.
Cons:
- It requires additional refuge land to divert the pests. The idea is that the susceptible pests will move to the refuge and other resistant pests will follow them for mating. Indian farmers with smaller holdings don't have this luxury and knowledge.
- High irrigation requirements. The crops have 100% failure in lack of water (20% for traditional seeds)
- Next generation seeds are not good. One needs to buy BT seeds again for the next season.
Problems pertaining to India:
- BT is meant for US and has no protection against leaf curl virus.
- The yields are not that high as promised. In Indonesia, the non GM (genetically modified) seeds have better yields.
- Some merchants in India are illegally selling second and third generation of BT seeds at much lower costs. Farmers are largely ignorant about this.
- and of course, the money lenders.
References:
http://www.cropchoice.com/leadstryfc7a.html?recid=888
http://www.sciencenews.org/articles/20030208/fob5.asp
Thanks Himanshu.. that was very useful.
Came across this interesting news: http://www.indianexpress.com/story/222012.html
Quoting from the article: BT-cotton seeds yield only high-quality medium and long staple cotton, and this has resulted in a severe shortage of low quality short staple cotton. This is adversely affecting the small-scale spinning and handloom sector, which employs 13 million workers and produces 20 per cent of India’s cloth. But interestingly, instead of asking for the usual dose of protectionist measures, the spinners have stressed that they are "not against the export of cotton if it is beneficial to farmers". It’s a sign of how India’s small-scale sector is maturing to the realities of a globalised world that they have asked the government to allow duty-free import of cotton to "create a balance in the market" to overcome the shortage and to bring down the cost of cotton. Interestingly, the south Indian spinners have asked for duty to be cut on all varieties.
My thoughts: Does this indicate that the fault is not with globalizing the market, but with not building sufficient safeguards to protect the farmers from global price fluctuations? This can be possibly be done through appropriate hedge funds, commodity futures trading, insurance schemes, and various other financial instruments. My point is that if India chooses to embrace the free-market ways of business, then it also needs to make sure that the associated risks are handled in the ways the free-market handles them. If not, then India has to operate in a totally different paradigm of socialist economies, or local economies, or something else, and handle the risks in that paradigm of economics.
Adi, I am curious how commodity futures protect the farmers from global fluctuations. If it is possible, can you please explain this very briefly?
I am sure things are way more complicated that this, but futures are essentially contracts between a buyer and a seller to buy/sell a certain product at a certain price at a certain date in the future. The contracts can then be traded on future-exchanges just like stocks are traded on stock-exchanges. So, you can imagine that farmers would agree to sell their produce at a certain price to some wholesaler. And then the contracts from many wholesalers and many types of produce would be aggregated by larger brokerage houses to hedge their risks from price fluctuations in some particular type of produce or from wholesalers in some particular geographical area. This is just like mutual funds have a portfolio of stocks, in a similar way commodity hedge funds have a portfolio of commodity futures.
India does have a commodity exchange http://www.iloveindia.com/finance/encyclopedia/multi-commodity-exchange.html but clearly, there is something amiss that it isn't able to handle global price fluctuations of cotton. This is something worth studying in detail.
Dear Friends,
Please extend you condelences on the "Death of Indian Farmer!", @http://prmadhura3.blogspot.com/
Another point of importance in this can be : lack of water to irrigate lands esp. in Saline Track of Vidarbha.
See www.hobaski.blogspot.com
Add new comment